Revision was approved, whether commissioners dissented, and who had access to the voter-data systems. The court hears the case on Tuesday.
New Delhi: The opposition has taken its fight over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls to a new stage. Leaders of the INDIA bloc have asked the Supreme Court for permission to put 48 questions to the Chief Election Commissioner, the other two Election Commissioners and senior officials, a day before the court resumes hearing the batch of petitions challenging the exercise.
What the bloc is asking for
The application, filed as part of the existing petitions, seeks the court’s approval for an “interrogatory”, a formal set of written questions to be answered with supporting records. It names Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu and the Director General of IT.
The petitioners argue that detailed answers backed by official records are needed to test the Election Commission’s claims. The Congress, which publicised the move on Monday, said the questions concern the “huge lapses” that it alleges paved the way for “vote chori”, its term for alleged manipulation of electoral rolls. The allegation is the opposition’s, and the Election Commission has rejected such charges.
The questions that have been reported
The full list has not been made public, but several of the questions have been described.
How the SIR was approved. One key question asks about the decision to launch a nationwide SIR, the approval process, and any differences among members of the Commission.
Dissent inside the Commission. The bloc wants details of every occasion between February 19, 2025 and October 26, 2026 when Sandhu or Joshi recorded an objection, dissent or reservation about the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 or election-related appeals. The Congress has framed it more simply, asking on how many decisions the other two commissioners disagreed with the CEC. The start date matches the day Kumar took charge as the head of the poll body.
The digital systems. A significant portion of the questions concerns ECINET and ERONET, the platforms used to manage electoral rolls, including who had access to voter data and who could alter records.
The Election Commission’s position
The Commission has already filed its counter-affidavit in the case. According to reports of its submission, it has said that an additional declaration introduced during the SIR was a separate document and not a change to Form 6, and that individual objections or comments recorded while files were being processed did not represent the final decisions of the Commission. The distinction matters because the opposition is looking for evidence of internal disagreement, while the Commission describes internal notes as part of the ordinary process of arriving at a decision.
Why the dissent question matters
The question of dissent did not come out of nowhere. Earlier this autumn, reports emerged that Sandhu and Joshi had written to the Cabinet Secretary in July over a disputed work-allocation order, and that they had separately recorded objections to decisions made in the Commission’s name. The Commission said at the time that those objections were part of its normal functioning and that its decisions, including on the SIR, were unanimous. The new application tries to turn that unresolved discussion into a matter of court record.
A procedural hurdle
The bloc’s request is a legal long shot in at least one respect. Interrogatories are more commonly associated with civil suits than with writ petitions, and it is unusual for a court to allow a constitutional body’s top officials to be questioned in this way. The court may also weigh how far it can go in testing the internal deliberations of an independent body, and whether the existing affidavits already cover the ground. The Commission is expected to oppose the application, though its response was not available at the time of writing.
What happens on Tuesday
A three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant is scheduled to hear the petitions on November 17. At the previous hearing on October 27, the court gave the petitioners 10 days to respond to the Commission’s counter-affidavit. The bench will now have to decide whether to entertain the request for questions, ask the Commission to respond to it, or leave it to the final hearing.
What to watch
Three questions will shape the next phase. Will the court allow any part of the interrogatory, or decide that the affidavits are enough? Will the Commission answer the dissent question in a court filing? And will the case, which began as a challenge to a voter-list exercise, become a broader test of how much the courts can examine the working of the poll body?
© Copyright 2026. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Vygr Media.












