Blog Banner
3 min read

Supreme Court Stays Order on Thiruparankundram Hilltop Lamp, but Allows Karthigai Deepam There on November 24 as a One-Time Exception

Calender Nov 20, 2026
3 min read

Supreme Court Stays Order on Thiruparankundram Hilltop Lamp, but Allows Karthigai Deepam There on November 24 as a One-Time Exception

For years, a small stone pillar on a hill in Madurai has been at the centre of a very large argument. On Friday, the Supreme Court gave an answer that is partly a pause and partly a permission: it stayed the Madras High Court’s order on the lamp ritual, but said the lamp can be lit at the disputed spot on Karthigai Deepam day this year, as a one-time measure.

Let’s break down what the court decided, what the dispute is about, and what each side is saying.

What the Supreme Court decided

On Friday, November 20, the Supreme Court stayed the Madras High Court judgment that had permitted the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam lamp at the Deepathoon, a stone pillar near a dargah on Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai. However, as a one-time measure, it allowed the lamp to be lit at the Deepathoon on November 24, the day of Karthigai Deepam this year.

In plain terms, there are two parts to the order.

Part of the order What it means
The stay The High Court’s directions are put on hold while the appeal is heard, so they do not become a standing right
The exception For this year’s festival only, the lamp can be lit at the Deepathoon on November 24

The reports I found do not spell out the conditions for the one-time exception, such as who will light the lamp or what security arrangements will apply. Those details should come with the written order.

What is the dispute about?

Thiruparankundram hill is home to the Arulmigu Subramania Swamy (Murugan) temple, a Kasi Viswanathan temple, Jain caves and the Sikandar Badusha dargah. It has long been described as a place where several faiths sit side by side.

The argument is about where the Karthigai Deepam lamp should be lit. The festival marks the Hindu festival of lights, and the lamp is lit on a hilltop for a couple of hours on the festival evening.

  • The traditional spot. For many years, the lamp has been lit at a lamp pavilion near the Uchi Pillaiyar temple.
  • The disputed spot. The Deepathoon is a stone lamp pillar on the hill, located about 50 metres from the dargah.

How the case reached the Supreme Court

When What happened
Early December 2025 A single judge of the Madras High Court’s Madurai Bench, Justice G R Swaminathan, directs that the lamp be lit at the Deepathoon and lets a petitioner and ten others go up the hill, with CISF security
Same days The state government refuses to allow it, stops activists from climbing the hill and moves the Supreme Court, citing possible law-and-order problems; the temple authority lights the lamp at the traditional spot instead
January 6, 2026 A division bench of the High Court upholds the single judge’s direction
November 17 to 19, 2026 The Supreme Court hears the state’s plea for a stay over three days
November 20, 2026 The court stays the High Court judgment but allows a one-time lighting on November 24


Thiruparankundram Hilltop Lamp

What each side argued

These are the arguments made in court, as reported.

Tamil Nadu government.

  • No custom exists of lighting the lamp at the Deepathoon.
  • Temple priests have said that under the Agamas, the lamp is lit at the traditional spot near the Uchi Pillaiyar temple.
  • The dargah claims ownership of the pillar under a 1923 decree.
  • The High Court wrongly assumed the top of the hill is where the lamp belongs, when the dargah stands there.
  • Earlier decisions did not allow the lamp at any other location, and a change could cause law-and-order trouble.

Those who sought to light the lamp.

  • The High Court’s order was “calibrated,” allowing only Devasthanam officials to go to the pillar on a single day, for a limited time.
  • Such a narrow direction, they argued, does not justify a stay.
  • They have pointed out that attempts to light the lamp there have been blocked before.

The Dargah Committee.

  • The High Court read the 1923 decree too narrowly.
  • The judge inspected the site without notifying the dargah.

None of these claims has been finally decided. The Supreme Court’s order is interim, and the appeal itself is still to be heard.

Why the exception matters

A stay without any exception would have meant no lamp at the Deepathoon this year, a result the petitioners would have seen as a defeat. Allowing a single lighting, while staying the wider order, lets the festival pass without a precedent being set either way. It leaves the main question, whether the lamp has a right to be lit there at all, for a full hearing.

In legal terms, “one-time measure” signals that the court is not deciding the underlying right. It is managing a time-sensitive situation while keeping the bigger issues open.

What it means for people on the ground

  • For devotees, the lamp can be lit at the Deepathoon on Karthigai Deepam day, November 24.
  • For the dargah community, the stay means the High Court’s order does not stand as a permanent direction for now.
  • For the state, it must manage the day, and the details of how will matter.
  • For future years, nothing is settled. The question could return next Karthigai Deepam if the appeal is not decided.

What happens next

Attention now turns to November 24, when the lamp is due to be lit. Police and local authorities will have to make arrangements, and the written order should clarify how. The Supreme Court will then hear the appeal against the High Court judgment on its merits, including the status of the 1923 decree, the claim of custom and the question of what a court can direct on a temple ritual. No date for that hearing has been reported.

What to watch next

Watch for the written order and its conditions, for the arrangements made on November 24, and for the response from the temple administration, Hindu outfits, the dargah committee, and political parties in Tamil Nadu. Also look for when the main appeal will be listed.

 

© Copyright 2026. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Vygr Media.

    • Apple Store
    • Google Play