The court described the offence as one that shook not just the judicial conscience but also the public conscience, and it declined to soften the ultimate penalty.
The written judgment is firm on the alternatives. The court held that any other punishment, including imprisonment for the rest of the convict's natural life without remission, would be inadequate and out of proportion to the crime. The judge writing the opinion added that his conscience did not allow him to commute the death penalty.
The outcome is not automatic in such cases. The Calcutta High Court itself commuted death sentences in a different five-year-old's rape-murder case in July 2025, citing the convicts' socio-economic background and a state report on their potential for reformation. In the Hooghly case, the Bench reached the opposite conclusion on the facts before it.
The crime: a child lured with chocolates in Gurap
The victim, a girl aged about five years and ten months, lived in the same neighbourhood as the convict in Gurap, in West Bengal's Hooghly district. She went missing from her home on November 24, 2024.
According to the prosecution case, her parents and neighbours searched for her and found her unconscious inside Ashok Singh's house. She was taken to Dhaniakhali Rural Hospital, where doctors declared her dead.
A neighbour told the trial court that she saw Singh take the child to his house on the pretext of giving her chocolates. Singh was arrested the same night by Gurap police.
From a 55-day trial to the High Court's death reference
The case moved unusually fast at the trial stage. The designated POCSO court at Chinsurah sentenced Singh to death on January 17, 2025, about 55 days after the crime. A chargesheet was filed within 14 days, and the in-camera trial began on December 18, 2024. In all, 27 witnesses were examined.
Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee publicly praised the court and the Hooghly Rural District Police for the speed of the probe and trial at the time.
A death sentence passed by a trial court cannot take effect until a High Court confirms it. The State therefore filed Death Reference No. 2 of 2025, and Singh filed his own appeal, CRA (DB) 328 of 2025. The Division Bench heard both together, reserved its judgment on October 6, 2026, and pronounced it on November 17, 2026.
|
Date |
Event |
|---|---|
|
Nov 24, 2024 |
Girl goes missing in Gurap and is found in the convict's house |
|
Dec 18, 2024 |
In-camera trial begins at the POCSO court, Chinsurah |
|
Jan 17, 2025 |
Trial court awards the death sentence |
|
Oct 6, 2026 |
Calcutta High Court reserves judgment |
|
Nov 17, 2026 |
High Court confirms the death sentence and dismisses the appeal |
Defence versus State: the evidence the court relied on
The defence argued that the case rested wholly on circumstantial evidence and that the chain of circumstances was incomplete. It questioned the neighbour's account, because she had not told the police or the Magistrate about it during the investigation. It also argued that the trial court imposed death without properly weighing mitigating factors, the chance of reform, or the option of imprisonment for the rest of his natural life.
The State, represented by Special Public Prosecutor Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee, replied that the child was last seen with Singh and was found in his room. It said forensic and medical evidence conclusively established his involvement.
The evidence the prosecution leaned on:
- Last-seen evidence: A neighbour said she saw Singh take the child to his house with the promise of chocolates.
- Recovery: The child was found unconscious inside his house and died at a rural hospital.
- Forensic link: DNA matching Singh was linked to samples collected from the child.
- Medical opinion: The post-mortem doctor held that the death was homicidal and followed sexual assault and serious head injuries.
The defence team included advocates Amit Ranjan Pati, Swastika Chowdhury, Ilika Nag, Yavik Singhal and Avijit Chatterjee, along with Senior Advocate Kaushik Gupta and Advocate Apalak Basu, who were appointed by the High Court Legal Services Committee.
Why the Bench ruled out reformation
Applying the Supreme Court's decision in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab and later rulings, the Bench held that even in a rarest-of-rare case a court must ask whether the convict can be reformed. It looked at his medical and psychological assessments and a Probation Officer's report.
|
Factor the court weighed |
Finding |
|---|---|
|
Age and background |
About 45 years old, illiterate, with no family at present |
|
Mental health |
No mental illness or psychological disorder shown |
|
Conduct towards others |
Two prosecution witnesses described alleged inappropriate conduct towards other girls in the neighbourhood |
|
Remorse |
None shown during examination under Section 313 CrPC, despite the forensic evidence |
|
Impact on family |
Lasting trauma to the child's parents |
On that record the court concluded there was no possibility of reformation.
Compensation raised to Rs 15 lakh as court flags State's lapse
The Bench called it unfortunate that the State had pressed for the death penalty while the victim's parents had still not received the Rs 10 lakh compensation directed earlier. It enhanced the amount to Rs 15 lakh and ordered the West Bengal Government to pay it within two months.
A compliance report is due by January 30, 2027. The Registrar General was also directed to send the judgment to Singh through the Superintendent of the correctional home, informing him of his right to appeal to the Supreme Court and to free legal aid.
Legal background: BNS, POCSO and the rarest-of-rare test
The trial court convicted Singh under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012, and awarded death for rape and murder. The Supreme Court's Bachan Singh framework reserves capital punishment for the rarest of rare cases and requires courts to weigh the circumstances of both the crime and the criminal, including whether reform is possible.
Parliament amended the POCSO Act in 2019 to allow the death penalty for aggravated penetrative sexual assault on a child below 12.
What happens next
- Singh can file an appeal in the Supreme Court, and the High Court has directed that he be told of his right to free legal aid.
- The West Bengal Government must pay Rs 15 lakh to the victim's parents within two months and report compliance by January 30, 2027.
- A death sentence is not carried out while an appeal or mercy petition remains available to the convict.
Frequently asked questions
Who did the Calcutta High Court sentence to death? Ashok Singh, for the rape and murder of a five-year-old girl in Gurap, Hooghly district.
When did the High Court confirm the death sentence? On November 17, 2026, after reserving judgment on October 6, 2026.
Which judges decided the case? Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray, a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court.
What is the case number? Death Reference No. 2 of 2025 (State of West Bengal v. Ashok Singh), heard with CRA (DB) 328 of 2025.
How much compensation did the court order? Rs 15 lakh, up from Rs 10 lakh, payable by the West Bengal Government within two months.
Can Ashok Singh appeal again? Yes. He can approach the Supreme Court, and the High Court directed that he be informed of his right to free legal aid.
Why did the court rule out life imprisonment? It found no possibility of reformation and held that a lesser punishment, even life without remission, would not match the crime.
© Copyright 2026. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Vygr Media.












